Grades 9–12: The Ice Age Earth System

All grade bands

High school students can treat the map as what it is: a model, built from other models and tested against field evidence. These lessons use it with the sea level curve under the slider, the ice age cycles graph on the Data page, and the Evidence layer. Each runs one or two class periods.

Each lesson is written for use with the Next Generation Science Standards*: it names the performance expectations it builds toward, linked to their official pages, with the core idea, practice and crosscutting concept each one combines. The steps follow the 5E sequence (engage, explore, explain, elaborate, evaluate). A single lesson builds toward a performance expectation; students meet it fully across a unit. See About the standards on the Educators page.

Lesson 1: What paces the ice ages?

Grades 9–12 · two 50-minute periods · pairs

Standards

  • HS-ESS2-4 Using a model of changes in the energy flowing into and out of Earth's systems to explain changes in climate, including the orbital changes behind the ice ages. Core idea ESS1.B, ESS2.A, ESS2.D · practice: developing and using models · crosscutting concept: cause and effect.

The phenomenon

The curve under the slider shows global sea level over 500,000 years. It rises and falls in a repeating pattern, about five times. What could make Earth's climate swing between ice ages and warm times on such a regular rhythm?

Steps

  • Engage. Students study the curve under the slider and describe its shape. How many cycles? How long is each? Is the rise as gradual as the fall?
  • Explore. Pairs read off the times of the five highest sea levels (warm interglacials) using the slider and the About this time card, and calculate the spacing. They should find roughly 100,000 years.
  • Explain. Introduce the three orbital cycles (eccentricity, about 100,000 and 400,000 years; obliquity, about 41,000; precession, about 23,000) and how they change the sunlight reaching high northern latitudes in summer. Ice sheets survive when summers are too cool to melt the winter's snow.
  • Elaborate. Open the ice age cycles graph on the Data page: 2.6 million years of sea level. Before about a million years ago the cycles were smaller and came about every 41,000 years; since then they have been larger and about 100,000 years apart (the Mid-Pleistocene Transition). Why the rhythm changed is still an open research question, often called the 100,000-year problem.
  • Evaluate. Students draw and annotate a model connecting orbit, summer sunlight, ice, and sea level, and use it to explain one rise on the curve.

Lesson 2: Slow to grow, fast to melt

Grades 9–12 · 50 minutes · pairs

Standards

  • HS-ESS2-2 Analyzing data to show that one change to Earth's surface can set off feedbacks that change other Earth systems. Core idea ESS2.A, ESS2.D · practice: analyzing and interpreting data · crosscutting concept: stability and change.

The phenomenon

On the curve, every ice age builds up slowly, over tens of thousands of years, and ends fast. After the last one, global sea level rose about 120 meters, most of it in about ten thousand years. Why would ice sheets melt so much faster than they grow?

Steps

  • Engage. Students sketch the sawtooth shape of one cycle from the curve and label the slow build-up and fast collapse.
  • Explore. Step from 24,000 to 7,500 years ago and record the ice and coasts at each step. Find the meltwater lakes along the ice edge (Lake Agassiz) and the land around Hudson Bay pressed down by the ice (see the FAQ on glacial isostatic adjustment).
  • Explain. Build a list of feedbacks with the class: bright ice reflects sunlight, so less ice means more warming (ice-albedo); a sinking ice surface sits in warmer air lower down; rising sea level floats and breaks up ice that rests on the sea floor; meltwater lakes undercut the ice edge. Most of them speed up melting once it begins; growing an ice sheet depends on snow piling up, year after year.
  • Evaluate. Students write a claim, supported by evidence from the map, that one change (a small rise in summer sunlight, for example) led through feedbacks to changes in the hydrosphere, cryosphere and geosphere.

Lesson 3: Testing a model against the evidence

Grades 9–12 · two 50-minute periods · pairs or small groups

Standards

  • HS-ESS3-6 Using the published results of computational models to show relationships among Earth's systems. Core idea ESS2.D, ESS3.D · practice: using mathematics and computational thinking · crosscutting concept: systems and system models.
  • HS-ESS3-5 Analyzing data and model results to forecast the rate of climate change and its impacts (here, the past as a baseline for future sea level). Core idea ESS3.D · practice: analyzing and interpreting data · crosscutting concept: stability and change.

The phenomenon

The coastlines on the map come from a computer model. The Evidence button adds real samples, shells, corals and peat, dated and measured, showing where the sea actually stood. Where do the model and the evidence agree, and where don't they?

Steps

  • Engage. Open 10,000 years ago, turn on Evidence, and click a few dots. Discuss what each color means (yellow: the sea stood at that height; blue: above it; brown: below it).
  • Explore. Groups each take one region (the North Sea, the US East Coast, Hudson Bay, the Mediterranean, Southeast Asia) and, at three or four steps, note where dots and the model coastline agree and disagree.
  • Explain. Groups report back. Agreement tends to be worse near the old ice sheets, where the answer depends on how thick the ice was and how the Earth's interior responded, and better far from them. Why might that be? Discuss what a model is, and why the map's Data page names several models for different times.
  • Elaborate. Connect to forecasts: today's sea level projections also come from models tested against observations. Students read the NASA Sea Level Projection Tool for a coast they know and identify what the forecast depends on and how certain it is.
  • Evaluate. A short written argument: how far should we trust a model of past or future sea level, and what evidence would change your mind?

Lesson 4: People and the shifting coast

Grades 9–12 · two 50-minute periods · small groups, with a short presentation

Standards

  • HS-ESS3-1 Explaining how natural resources, hazards and changes in climate have influenced human activity, including sea level change driving migration. Core idea ESS3.A, ESS3.B · practice: constructing explanations · crosscutting concept: cause and effect.
  • HS-LS4-5 Evaluating evidence that changes in environmental conditions can lead to more of some species, new species, and the extinction of others. Core idea LS4.C · practice: engaging in argument from evidence · crosscutting concept: cause and effect.

The phenomenon

Some of the best land people lived on during the last ice age is now under the sea. How did the changing coasts and climate shape where people lived and moved?

Steps

  • Engage. Show Sundaland at 24,000 years ago, a subcontinent of lowland joining Sumatra, Java and Borneo to Asia, and ask where people would have lived.
  • Explore. Each group takes one case: Beringia and the first Americans; Doggerland in the North Sea; Sundaland and Sahul (Australia and New Guinea); the Green Sahara at 7,500 years ago; or the Black Sea as a lake. They find their place on the map at several times and research the human story with sources you provide.
  • Explain. Groups present a claim about how the change in coast or climate affected people, with evidence from the map and from their sources.
  • Elaborate. Bring it to the present: billions of people live near coasts today. Which of the historical cases is most like what coastal communities face now, and which is least like it?
  • Evaluate. The presentation, scored on claim, evidence and reasoning.

*Next Generation Science Standards is a registered trademark of WestEd. Neither WestEd nor the lead states and partners that developed the Next Generation Science Standards were involved in the production of this product, and do not endorse it.